Live 5
EN
FR - French AR - Arabic EN - English

Pirates, Sundowns and Chiefs chase Carling Knockout final spots – but who has the best record?

The three South African giants have very different records
Africa
Add Foot Africa on Google
Pirates, Sundowns and Chiefs chase Carling Knockout final spots – but who has the best record?
Chiefs

The Carling Knockout semi-finals could set up a final featuring two of South African football's biggest clubs, with Orlando Pirates, Mamelodi Sundowns and Kaizer Chiefs all still in contention.

Big Three target Carling Knockout final places

Pirates travel to Moses Mabhida Stadium to face Stellenbosch on Saturday, before Sundowns host Chiefs at Loftus Versfeld on Sunday.

At least one of the Big Three is guaranteed a place in the final, which is currently scheduled for December 12. The date will be moved if Sundowns qualify.

For the sponsors and many supporters, the ideal outcome would be a final between two of the three giants, with Pirates facing either Chiefs or Sundowns.

Read Also: Super Eagles miss chance to go top after stalemate against Tanzania

Since Carling took over as sponsors, the competition has not featured two of the Big Three in its final. The last domestic cup final involving two of them was in 2010.

Across the PSL era, Pirates have reached the most domestic cup finals, while Chiefs boast the strongest winning record.

How Pirates, Sundowns and Chiefs compare in cup finals

Orlando Pirates – 15 wins from 29 finals

The Buccaneers have won 15 of their 29 domestic cup finals, giving them a success rate of 51.7%.

Their first PSL-era trophy came on November 23, 1996, when Andries Sebola scored the only goal in a 1-0 victory over Jomo Cosmos in the BOB Save Super Bowl.

Pirates are also the holders of the Carling Cup. Their most recent final appearance was the 2026 MTN8, where they lost 2-0 to Sundowns.

Mamelodi Sundowns – 11 wins from 26 finals

Sundowns have reached 26 domestic cup finals since their first in 1997, when they lost the Rothmans Cup final to Chiefs on penalties.

Their first PSL-era cup triumph came in the 1998 Bob Save Super Bowl. After two 1-1 draws against Pirates, the Brazilians won 6-5 on penalties.

They have since won 11 of their 26 finals, a success rate of 42%. Their most recent triumph was the 2026 MTN8.

Kaizer Chiefs – 16 wins from 23 finals

Chiefs have the strongest record of the three, winning 16 of their 23 domestic cup finals for a 70% success rate.

Their most recent trophy was the 2025 Nedbank Cup, which ended an 11-year wait for domestic cup silverware.

Before that, their last domestic cup success came in September 2014, when they edged Pirates in the MTN8 final.

Chiefs' first PSL-era cup triumph was the 1997 Rothmans Cup.

Read Also: Official: Senegal qualify for AFCON 2027

This article follows our newsroom’s editorial standards. To learn more about how we create and fact-check our content, see our Editorial Policy .
Mmenyeneabasi Akpan

Mmenyeneabasi Akpan |

Editorfr, ar, en

Exclusive Interviews
Comments
Only registered users can leave or reply to comments.