Surprise in CAF Awards 2026 rules.. Excluding 3.5 months from the race flips calculations for Hakimi, Mane and Brahim Diaz
The Confederation of African Football (CAF) has confirmed that the 2026 African Player of the Year award will be decided using performances recorded between 1 January and 15 September, rather than the full calendar year.
The clarification, published on Wednesday 18 November, reveals an important distinction between the year printed on the trophy and the period actually assessed to determine its winner.
In its official explanation of the voting process, CAF confirmed that performances at both club and international level are considered, but only within the designated assessment window.
That means goals, trophies and outstanding performances achieved after 15 September fall outside the published evaluation period for the 2026 edition, even though the ceremony takes place almost three months later.
Why does CAF close the assessment so early?
The most immediate explanation lies in the organisation of the selection and voting process.
CAF must first assess performances, identify nominees through a panel of football experts and subsequently allow eligible voters to select the winners.
The 2026 nominees were announced on 4 November, with voting scheduled between 5 and 20 November, ahead of the 2 December ceremony in Lagos.
The process involves national-team coaches and captains, representatives of CAF's 54 member associations, eligible club representatives, technical experts and journalists. Independent firm PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) monitors the voting process.
Establishing an earlier performance cutoff allows these stages to take place before the awards ceremony, rather than requiring voters to assess matches still being played.
However, CAF has not publicly explained why 15 September was selected specifically, rather than a later date.
The administrative timetable helps explain the need for a cutoff, but it does not establish why almost three and a half months of the calendar year are excluded.
Is September always the deadline?
No. A comparison with previous editions shows that CAF's evaluation window is not fixed.
In 2023, meanwhile, men's performances were assessed between November 2022 and September 2023.
The variation suggests that CAF adjusts the assessment period between editions rather than applying a permanent September deadline.
It also exposes a less obvious question, the 2025 assessment ended on 15 October while the 2026 window began on 1 January.
Consequently, performances between 16 October and 31 December 2025 fall outside both published assessment windows.
CAF's latest explanation does not address how such gaps between editions are handled.
What does this mean for Hakimi, Mané and the other nominees?
The distinction matters in a race featuring some of African football's biggest names.
As Foot Africa reported when CAF unveiled its ten-man shortlist, defending champion Achraf Hakimi faces competition from Sadio Mane, Brahim Diaz, Antoine Semenyo, Amad Diallo and five other contenders.
Their performances at the Africa Cup of Nations 2025 which concluded in January 2026, the FIFA World Cup and major club competitions can all contribute to their cases within the assessment period.
However, an outstanding display in October or November cannot formally add to a player's 2026 evaluation record under the published cutoff.
That creates a potential difference between the player enjoying the strongest form when the trophy is presented and the player judged to have performed best during CAF's designated window.
The two are not necessarily the same.
Ultimately, CAF's African Player of the Year award recognises excellence within a defined period, not necessarily across all 365 days of the calendar year.