Bizarre VAR mistaken identity rule sparks laughter as American squad crushes Paraguay

World Cup 2026 Today at 16:29

Khaled Hegazy

News Editor

12.06.26 FT World Cup

USA

4

:

Paraguay

1

Refereeing history was made in the USA on Saturday 13 Jun when a brand-new VAR rule caused hilarious confusion during a massive World Cup clash.

The United States launched their home tournament in spectacular fashion, completely dismantling Paraguay to secure a massive 4-1 victory 32 year after they last hosted the global event.

However the most talked-about moment of the match had nothing to do with the brilliant goals. According to the British newspaper The Sun, American defender Tim Ream initially received a yellow card after Paraguayan winger Miguel Almiron went down under a heavy challenge.

Dutch referee Danny Makkelie was absolutely convinced that the veteran center-back had committed a cynical foul to halt the attack.

Reversing the decision

This is where the newly implemented Video Assistant Referee protocol stepped in. For the first time in FIFA history, VAR officials are explicitly authorized to intervene and correct the on-field referee regarding mistaken identity for colored cards.

The video booth immediately instructed Makkelie to consult the pitch side monitor. Upon reviewing the replay, the official realized Ream made absolutely no illegal contact. Makkelie completely reversed his original decision, wiped the yellow card from Ream's record and shockingly booked Almiron instead for blatant simulation.

Fans react to the chaos

This unprecedented sequence of events instantly triggered a massive wave of amusement across social media platforms. Supporters flooded the internet to mock the strange, theatrical nature of the reversal.

Football fans heavily praised the bizarre yet effective protocol, with many calling it the funniest sequence ever witnessed on the global stage, openly enjoying the instant karma delivered to the diving attacker.

The ghost of Stamford Bridge

While this modern technology smoothly resolved Saturday's drama, football fans have painfully endured mistaken identity disasters before VAR existed.

The most infamous Premier League example occurred in 2014 during a massive London derby between Arsenal & Chelsea. Arsenal midfielder Alex Oxlade Chamberlain deliberately handled the ball inside the penalty area to stop a goal but referee Andre Marriner inexplicably showed a straight red card to his completely innocent teammate, Kieran Gibbs.

Despite Oxlade Chamberlain actively confessing to the referee on the pitch, the incorrect dismissal stood, utterly ruining the integrity of the match.

Related teams and leagues

USA

Paraguay

World Cup